Why I'll Never Make Martha Stewart's Famous Potato Salad Recipe Again The Kitchn The Only Sweater Dress You Need In Your Closet This Winter The Glamorous Gleam Dill Buttermilk Dip with Winter Crudites Martha's much loved family recipe for potato salad stars steamed red potatoes in a tangy, creaming dressing. While they are still warm, the potatoes are peeled, sliced, and tossed with white vinegar. Then Blue Cheese Dressing Punchfork